Value investing: Momentum’s Tom Delic on why investors should focus on Benjamin Graham’s principles

Having been in consistent print since its first publication in 1949, Benjamin Graham’s ‘Intelligent Investor’ has, along with ‘Security Analysis’, provided the philosophical foundation to thousands of successful investment practitioners over the decades.  However, as Mark Twain said, “A classic is something that everybody wants to have read, and nobody wants to read”.  Open almost any page of those two texts however, and your mind will be enriched with the ideas and thoughts of Graham, and like most literature that has survived the test of time, you will soon realise why.

The concepts laid down by Graham over 70 years ago sets an investor up with a sound, rational, mental framework to deal with the vicissitudes of a hyper-active stock market, that swings between the emotions of a broken-hearted teenager and a toddler’s first taste of chocolate.  But what does Graham not say?  Is the consensus view of value investing in line with the thinking of Graham or has time distorted and twisted the interpretation?

Leaning on the work of Eugene Fama and Kenneth French, investing is often reduced to nothing more than quantitative pigeonholing.  A fund manager strategy or a point-in-time valuation ratio of a listed equity can then be boxed neatly into categories, pitted against one another in an endless race where investors are pressured to pick a side.  Today, the consensus is “value” investing is losing the race, with “growth” investing in an unassailable lead.  Perhaps though, there are no “style” sides and instead a footrace exists between investment and speculation, which can often feel like a marathon.  This takes us back to Graham.

Graham’s core tenets seek to teach us how to act like investors rather than speculators.  The margin of safety concept sits at the heart of this approach and simply advises that the investor should only purchase securities where a gap exists between their conservative estimate of intrinsic value, and the price at which the security is being offered.  In Graham’s words, “the function of the margin of safety is, in essence, that of rendering unnecessary an accurate estimate of the future”.

The example of Microsoft provides an illustrative example of Graham’s concept in practice.  From 1999 to 2012, Microsoft’s free cash flow yield increased from 1.6% to 13.1%[1], with equity holders of the company suffering a -42% total return over the period[2].  The speculative era of 1999 had faded away and in 2012, an opportunity for a conservative investor was available.

Value investing today is assumed to be a blind investment in the optically cheap but in ‘Security Analysis’, Graham emphasises that “an investment operation is one that can be justified on both qualitative and quantitative grounds”.  A cursory glance at the data in 2012 would have shown you that despite the share price halving since 1999, the business was fundamentally strong, with consistent revenue and cash flow growth over the period[3] and Microsoft Windows remaining the dominant operating system in an ever-increasing world of computer usage.

The narrative around the company was certainly not as rosy however, with headlines such as ‘Microsoft’s Lost Decade’[4] and “Microsoft once ruled the world. So, what went wrong?”[5].  Turning to Graham’s principles once more, he states “You are neither right nor wrong because the crowd disagrees with you. You are right because your data and reasoning are right.”  A margin of safety and the courage to act against the crowd would have resulted in a successful investment in Microsoft, as the investors of 2012 have handed the reins back to the speculators of 2020-21, which has seen the company move to a free cash flow yield of 2.7%.

In a period of frenzied and excitable divorcement of price and fundamental value, as we have seen over the past couple of years, the speculators rule the roost, with investors flapping for a perch.  There is no universal law to help investors second guess when a change will occur.  Instead, investors should stay focused on Graham’s principles to ensure they are acting with a margin of safety using their own analysis.  This is what value investing truly is.

Tom Delic, Fund Manager at Momentum Global Investment Management

[1] Bloomberg

[2] Bloomberg

[3] Bloomberg

[4] Vanity Fair, August 2012

[5] Guardian, August 2012

Featured News

This Week’s Most Read

  • Price of scarcity: Central banks are driving large valuation premiums on assets with limited supply

    By Charles-Henry Monchau, CIO at Syz Bank It is important to understand the concept of scarcity to better understand its mechanics and its impact on markets. Scarcity refers to the

  • Why now is the right time to invest in Japan

    By Masakazu Takeda, lead portfolio manager of the Japan Focus All Cap strategy at SPARX Asset Management The issues that have plagued Japan over the years are now at the doorstep of

  • Why high yield bonds could be the next ESG frontier

    By Lila Fekih & Mark Remington, Co-Portfolio Managers of the New Capital Sustainable World High-Yield Bond Fund at EFG Asset Management  Equities have garnered the most attention in the ESG

  • Fundsmith hints at bumpy ride

    Terry Smith’s annual letter to shareholders reports a slight underperformance of the MSCI World Index over one year Despite the value rally, quality stocks outperformed in 2021 Smith says unexpectedly

  • Brooks Macdonald Funds under Management hit £17.3bn

    Brooks Macdonald today publishes an update on its Funds under Management (“FUM”) for its second quarter ended 31 December 2021, together with a Trading Update for the half year. FUM

  • Ninety One appoints Juliana Hansveden

    Hansveden to develop emerging markets sustainable equity capability Ninety One has today announced the appointment of Juliana Hansveden, CFA, as Portfolio Manager, Emerging Markets Sustainable Equity. In this newly created

  • Man GLG’s Atherton: Governance revolution in Japan like the UK in the 80s and 90s

    The ESG-driven corporate governance revolution in Japan is creating investment opportunities similar to those in the UK in the 1980s and 1990s, says Jeff Atherton, manager of the Man GLG

  • US December CPI inflation rises 7% from a year ago

    David Goebel, Investment Strategist at Tilney Smith & Williamson, the wealth management and professional services group, comments on the latest US CPI inflation data: US December headline CPI inflation rose

  • BlackRock launches two new active Climate Action funds

    The BGF Climate Action Multi-Asset Fund and the BGF Climate Action Equity Fund leverage BlackRock’s deep expertise in active sustainable investing with the objective of generating positive environmental impact.  As

Wealth DFM