Are we just kidding ourselves? @AICPress Ian Sayers comments on Aviva UK Property Fund

by | May 20, 2021

global property

A friend once told me that, if what people put down on their health insurance forms about the alcohol they consumed was extrapolated across the entire population, it would account for just half of UK alcohol sales. ‘They just blatantly lie,’ he concluded.

Even if the data supports his claim, I am not sure he is right to conclude that the majority of us consciously and blatantly lie. As humans, we tend to think our best behaviour is more common than it is. So, we think a ‘good’ week alcohol wise is closer to an average one than it is, we forget the third glass of wine we had over dinner at the weekend, and ignore the 40th birthdays, weddings, leaving dos etc because, well, they don’t happen every year do they?

I was reminded of this as I read about the sad fate of Aviva UK Property Fund which, having been suspended for 14 months, has decided to go into liquidation, which means investors may have to wait another two years for their money back, so more than three years in total.

Yet the industry response to the FCA’s consultations about the length of notice period that should be applied to prevent these kinds of problems concluded that 90 days would be sufficient to allow managers to sell properties to meet redemptions. How do we explain this huge disparity in timescales?

A report by the Bank of England/FCA recently noted, where open-ended bond funds are concerned, that managers ‘appeared to overestimate the liquidity of their holdings, and for some funds were particularly overoptimistic’. I would suggest the same is happening for property funds. I am sure that some property funds might be able to sell some assets in 90 days in normal market conditions, but how common is this?

Also, to meet international standards, funds should be able to cater for stressed market conditions as well, which is when redemption pressure is often the greatest. And even if a fund could offload some properties in this timeframe, these are likely to be the most attractive and easiest to sell – potentially leaving investors who remain in the fund exposed to a very different, and less liquid, portfolio.

Adequate notice periods would prevent the need to hold large tranches of cash, would allow managers to sell properties in an orderly way at a decent price, and avoid the need for suspensions which could ultimately lead to liquidation. But all the evidence shows that 180 days, let alone 90, will not be sufficient, which is why the AIC suggested a year, as is required in Germany where they have a thriving and growing sector.

A more prudent approach to notice periods is essential, as plans for a long-term asset fund will allow open-ended funds to invest in assets that are far more complex and illiquid than property. But, as I commented earlier this month, the LTAF won’t be subject to all of the same regulatory rules that apply to open-ended property funds. This means that a fund could launch as an LTAF and hold the same portfolio as the Aviva fund, but its investors would not benefit from these protections.

We have never suggested (as some commentators have) that open-ended funds should be banned from holding illiquid assets. Nor do we have any problem with the launch of the LTAF, providing it is safe for consumers and the wider economy and allows competition on a fair basis.

So if this can be achieved, we are happy to raise a glass along with others when the LTAF is launched. But unless we are honest with ourselves and behave sensibly, we shouldn’t be surprised if we wake up with a hangover.

Related articles

Argentina devalues peso, slashes public spending

Argentina devalues peso, slashes public spending

(Sharecast News) - Argentina's new hard-right government has devalued its currency by more than half in its first package of economic measures that include slashing public spending. The plans, unveiled by economy minister Luis Caputo in a televised address, also...

OPEC+ agrees to cut output by a further 1m barrels a day

OPEC+ agrees to cut output by a further 1m barrels a day

(Sharecast News) - OPEC+ members have reportedly agreed to cut oil production by a further one million barrels a day. In an online meeting, the cartel of oil producing nations- led by Saudi Arabic - said the production cuts would begin early next year. According to...

Gold and oil prices jump on geopolitical unrest

Gold and oil prices jump on geopolitical unrest

(Sharecast News) - Commodity prices continued to rise on Friday, as tensions escalated across the Middle East. Gold, traditionally seen as a safe haven asset, pushed past $1,980 an ounce, with Comex gold futures adding nearly 1% at $1,980.60, the highest since May....

Trending stories

Join our mailing list

Subscribe to our mailing list to receive regular updates!