Three reasons ESG investors should beware Bitcoin 

by | Apr 27, 2021

It is no exaggeration to say that the cryptocurrency is antithetical to each of the three principles – Environment, Social and Governance – that make up the ESG acronym. Here, CG Asset Management fund manager Chris Clothier examines the reasons why.

  1. Bitcoin is nothing short of an environmental catastrophe. It is estimated to consume as much electricity as the Netherlands* and have a carbon footprint equal to the entire country of New Zealand. Bitcoin “miners” are in a race to complete the proof of work against other miners. The winner of each race (which occurs every 10 minutes or so) is awarded new coins. As the value of Bitcoin has risen, so the prize for “winning” increases and Bitcoin miners are incentivised to deploy ever greater resources in pursuit of victory. These resources take the form of vast, air conditioned server farms, a significant proportion of which are based in China and rely on coal power. Bitcoin is much less efficient than the networks it aims to replace. It is estimated that a single transaction on the Bitcoin network uses as much energy as 500,000 transactions on Visa.
  2. Bitcoin also harbours negative social effects. The anonymity it offers provides today’s drug traffickers, money launderers, child pornographers, extortionists, and terrorists a ‘safe space’ to conduct their transactions, away from the eyes of the law and regulators.
  3. On governance, there are also concerns. The fundamental attraction of Bitcoin to its advocates – that of a decentralized network incapable of being debased by government fiat or coopted by illiberal diktat – presents its own challenges. With no depositary, central register, or formal governance arrangements, there is no one that an investor can turn to when their bitcoin is lost, stolen or their password forgotten.  There are also persistent rumours that the price of Bitcoin is being manipulated by bad actors. Whether true or not, the lack of regulatory oversight makes manipulation more probable than in mainstream markets.

Chris Clothier, Fund Manager, CGAM, said: “Anonymity in financial markets has been in decline for decades. Libertarian ideals have been ranged against the legislative and coercive powers of the state. It has not been a fair fight; states have won and society at large has accepted the outcome. The benefits of financial anonymity to law abiding individuals are modest, yet the costs to society from criminal exploitation of anonymity are great and take the form of tax evasion, money laundering, and financing of terrorism. By setting itself outside of – and in opposition to – the prevailing trend against financial anonymity Bitcoin could yet attract the attention of regulators and see itself heavily marginalised or even replaced by a “better” digital currency.

“Like any other human institution, Bitcoin is capable of reform but its decentralised nature makes change cumbersome. Whether it is able to reform while retaining its appeal among its proponents remains to be seen. For the time being, investors with any consideration for ESG principles should avoid it.”



Related articles

Argentina devalues peso, slashes public spending

Argentina devalues peso, slashes public spending

(Sharecast News) - Argentina's new hard-right government has devalued its currency by more than half in its first package of economic measures that include slashing public spending. The plans, unveiled by economy minister Luis Caputo in a televised address, also...

OPEC+ agrees to cut output by a further 1m barrels a day

OPEC+ agrees to cut output by a further 1m barrels a day

(Sharecast News) - OPEC+ members have reportedly agreed to cut oil production by a further one million barrels a day. In an online meeting, the cartel of oil producing nations- led by Saudi Arabic - said the production cuts would begin early next year. According to...

Gold and oil prices jump on geopolitical unrest

Gold and oil prices jump on geopolitical unrest

(Sharecast News) - Commodity prices continued to rise on Friday, as tensions escalated across the Middle East. Gold, traditionally seen as a safe haven asset, pushed past $1,980 an ounce, with Comex gold futures adding nearly 1% at $1,980.60, the highest since May....

Trending stories

Join our mailing list

Subscribe to our mailing list to receive regular updates!